Back

Free weekday email: what moved overnight, and what it changes.

Get the Daily Briefor the In-Depth Edition
November 16, 2026 | United States

Schmid Says Inflation Is Still a Demand Problem: Why the December Case Rests on the Real Rate

7 min read 0

Kansas City Fed President Jeff Schmid rejected the two explanations that would let the committee hold rates in December: that supply shocks are beyond its control, and that AI-driven demand is immune to borrowing costs. With PCE inflation at 3.6% and the funds rate at 3.75% to 4.00%, the ex-post real policy rate is about a quarter of a point.

Data as of November 16, 2026.

The argument inside the Federal Reserve is no longer about when to cut. It is about which explanation of inflation the committee is willing to accept, because that answer sets the size of the increase markets now expect at the December 8-9 meeting.

What Schmid said, and what he was arguing against

Kansas City Fed President Jeff Schmid told a credit union conference in Hawaii on Sunday that inflation is "uncomfortably above the 2% price stability target, and moving in the wrong direction," and that the central bank "has some work to do on inflation." He did not call for a particular increase, and he does not vote on the FOMC this year. The substance of the remarks was narrower and more useful than a rate recommendation: he attacked two explanations of inflation that have become common in the policy debate.

The first is that repeated supply shocks, energy above all, have driven the current price level and that monetary policy is therefore a blunt instrument against it. "Inflation is always the result of an imbalance between supply and demand," Schmid said. "It is in the context of strong demand that a disruption to supply drives up prices."

The second is that the parts of demand now growing fastest, principally the buildout of artificial intelligence infrastructure, are insensitive to borrowing costs. Schmid rejected the premise that price stability requires a response from any particular set of prices, including AI-related technology goods.

Both claims, he argued, share a conclusion he does not accept: that inflation is beyond the Fed's power to control. That is the sentence that matters for December. A committee that believes it is facing an external shock can wait. A committee that believes it is facing demand can act, and is responsible for doing so.

The arithmetic Schmid is talking about

The gap is not a matter of interpretation. The personal consumption expenditures price index, the measure the Fed targets, rose 3.6% in the twelve months to September, after 3.4% in August and July and 3.5% in June, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The next reading is scheduled for November 25. That leaves the September figure as the official state of play five weeks before the vote, and it is 1.6 percentage points above target.

The October consumer price index, published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics on November 10, rose 0.4% on the month, with the core measure excluding food and energy at 0.3%. That is the third consecutive month at 0.3%. Compounded over twelve months, 1.003 to the twelfth power is 1.0366, so three months of "only" 0.3% is running at roughly 3.7% annualized. Producer prices for October, published November 13, rose 6.5% over twelve months, the fastest annual pace since November 2022.

Against that, the target range for the federal funds rate has sat at 3.75% to 4.00% since the quarter-point increase in September, held there at the October 27-28 meeting. The midpoint of that range is 3.875%. Subtract the 3.6% PCE inflation rate and the ex-post real policy rate is roughly 0.28 percentage points. A rate that clears inflation by a quarter of a point sits below the real policy rates that four central banks were running in October, and is not restrictive in any ordinary sense, which is precisely why the supply-shock story carries so much weight for those who want to pause: it is the only story in which the current stance is defensible without further tightening.

There is a second piece of arithmetic worth holding onto. Closing a 1.6 point gap from 3.6% to 2% requires cumulative monthly price increases that run below the current pace for a sustained stretch. At 0.2% a month, which is the rate consistent with target over time, the gap closes in about eight months. At 0.3%, it does not close at all. The difference between those two paths is the whole of the December debate, and no single data release resolves it.

The committee is not of one mind on pace

The dispersion inside the FOMC is wider than the market pricing suggests. Governor Christopher Waller has said he would support a quarter-point increase in December and that a half-point move should be considered if core inflation prints around 0.3% or higher. Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan has argued for at least two additional quarter-point increases followed by a pause. Boston Fed President Susan Collins said on Saturday that "a steady, gradual path seems appropriate to me at the moment," noting that the rise in medium and longer term rates since the start of the year may be restraining demand more than she had assumed. Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee described the October inflation report as "borderline disturbing."

Interest rate futures now fully price a quarter-point increase at the December 8-9 meeting, with a small probability attached to half a point. Schmid's contribution was not a vote count. It was an attempt to remove the intellectual escape hatch that would let the committee hold again without arguing that inflation is somebody else's problem.

The distinction between the two positions is about the transmission channel, not about hawkishness. Collins and Schmid agree that inflation is too high. They differ on how much of the restraint is already in the pipeline from market rates, and therefore on how fast the policy rate itself must move. When the ten-year has already done part of the work, the same destination requires fewer moves. That argument is testable, which is why the long end matters as much as the funds rate in the next three weeks.

What reaches households first

The practical stake is the cost of new borrowing. The Freddie Mac primary mortgage survey put the thirty-year fixed rate near 7.18% in the most recent reading, and the mortgage spread against the matching Treasury yield has been the binding constraint on household payments for two years. A December increase does not move existing fixed-rate mortgages. It moves home equity lines, auto lending, card pricing tied to a prime rate, and the discount rate applied to every future cash flow in an equity valuation.

For a household refinancing or buying, the relevant number is not the funds rate but the mortgage spread. That spread has run well above its pre-2022 range, which is why a policy rate 2.2 points below its 2023 peak has not produced a proportionate fall in payments. Rate increases transmitted through a wide spread arrive at the borrower amplified, not damped.

What to watch before December 8-9

Three observable items settle the question Schmid raised. The November 25 PCE release shows whether the September acceleration continued, and it lands before the meeting, which makes it the last official inflation reading the committee will see. The FOMC statement itself is the second: language that still attributes elevated inflation primarily to external price pressures would signal a smaller move than futures imply. The third is the vote count and the dissents, which reveal whether the gradual camp or the two-hike camp holds the majority going into 2027.

There is also a structural question the December meeting will not answer. Inflation has now run above target for more than five years. The September increase was the first in this cycle, and the October hold reversed the direction of travel within six weeks. Whatever the December outcome, the committee is deciding it with a policy rate barely above measured inflation, an unemployment rate that has stayed stable, and a producer price index accelerating at the wholesale level. Those three facts sit awkwardly together, and no rhetorical frame makes them sit better.

A rate decision is a statement about which of those facts the committee believes is temporary. Schmid spent a Sunday afternoon arguing that none of them are.

Global Financial Info. (2026, November 16). Schmid Says Inflation Is Still a Demand Problem: Why the December Case Rests on the Real Rate. Global Financial Info. https://globalfinancialinfo.info/article/schmid-inflation-demand-problem-real-rate-december-hike-november-16-2026

Free for noncommercial use under Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0. Commercial licensing: partners@globalfinancialinfo.info